How to Choose the Right Chicago Neighborhood for You

One of the first questions people ask when they're thinking about moving within Chicago is:

“What neighborhood should I live in?”

It's a reasonable question. It's also one that doesn't have a universal answer.

Chicago is a city of neighborhoods, and the experience of living here can change considerably depending on where you are. Housing types, transportation, density, access to the lake, parks, restaurants, shopping, parking, and even the amount of space you can get for your budget can vary from one neighborhood to another.

Rather than starting with someone else's list of the “best” Chicago neighborhoods, I generally think it's more useful to start with how you want to live and what you want your housing budget to accomplish.

Here are some of the things worth considering.

Start With the Housing, Not Just the Neighborhood Name

People sometimes become attached to a particular neighborhood before looking closely at what their budget will actually buy or rent there.

I'd reverse that process.

Start by thinking about the type of home you want:

• condo or apartment

• single-family home

• townhome

• vintage building or newer construction

• high-rise or smaller building

• number of bedrooms and bathrooms

• outdoor space

• parking

• elevator

• in-unit laundry

• central air

• pet considerations

Then look at where those options exist within your budget.

You may discover that the home you want is readily available in several neighborhoods you hadn't originally considered.

And sometimes expanding the search by just a few blocks can meaningfully change the available inventory.

Think About Your Actual Commute

A neighborhood can look close to your workplace on a map and still produce a commute you don't enjoy making every day.

If you rely on public transportation, look at which CTA train and bus routes serve the areas you're considering and how you'll actually get from your home to the places you regularly need to go.

If you drive, consider highway access, traffic patterns, and parking.

And if you work from home most of the time, your priorities may be completely different. An extra bedroom or dedicated workspace might matter more than shaving ten minutes off an occasional commute.

Rather than asking whether a neighborhood has “good transportation,” ask:

Does the transportation work for where I actually need to go?

Decide How Much Space Matters

One of the fundamental tradeoffs in urban real estate is often location versus space.

The amount and type of housing available at a particular price can change significantly across Chicago and the surrounding suburbs.

Would you rather have a smaller condo closer to the places you frequent, or more living space farther away?

Would you trade a second bedroom for a better location?

Is outdoor space more important than being close to the lake?

Would you consider a neighborhood you hadn't originally planned on if it meant getting a garage, an extra bedroom, or a larger home?

There isn't a correct answer. But knowing where you're willing to compromise makes the search considerably easier.

Consider the Type of Building You Want

Chicago isn't just a collection of different neighborhoods. It's also a collection of very different types of housing.

You can find:

• downtown and lakefront high-rises

• courtyard buildings

• vintage walk-ups

• lofts

• condominiums

• two- and three-flats

• townhomes

• single-family homes

• newer mid-rise developments

The building itself can affect your experience just as much as the neighborhood.

Someone who wants a doorman, elevator, fitness center, and attached parking may naturally consider different properties than someone who wants a small building, private outdoor space, and fewer shared amenities.

If you're buying a condominium, building characteristics also affect assessments, reserves, rules, maintenance responsibilities, and other ownership considerations.

Look Beyond the Home's Purchase Price

For buyers, affordability isn't just the list price.

Property taxes, condominium assessments, parking, insurance, utilities, maintenance, and other expenses all contribute to the actual cost of owning a particular home.

That can make comparing neighborhoods and property types less straightforward than simply looking at prices online.

For example, a condominium with a lower purchase price but substantially higher monthly assessments may have a different overall cost than another property with a higher price and lower assessments.

When comparing homes, I prefer to look at the complete housing expense, not just the number on the listing.

Think About the Places You Actually Use

When people research neighborhoods online, they often focus on lists of attractions.

But living somewhere is different from visiting it.

Think about the places that are part of your normal routine.

Do you care about being able to walk to a grocery store? Do you regularly use the lakefront or parks? Do you want restaurants and coffee shops nearby? How important is access to a gym, transit, shopping, healthcare, or other everyday services?

Rather than asking whether a neighborhood has “a lot to do,” ask whether it provides convenient access to the things you actually do.

That's a much more useful test.

Visit at Different Times

If you're unfamiliar with an area, don't evaluate it solely during a 20-minute property showing.

Spend some time there.

Walk around. Visit a coffee shop. Go to the grocery store. Try the commute. Look at parking. Come back at another time of day.

A Saturday afternoon and a Tuesday morning can give you very different perspectives on the same location.

This is especially valuable if you're relocating to Chicago and trying to narrow down neighborhoods based primarily on internet research.

Online research can help you create a shortlist. It can't tell you how you will experience a location.

Don't Let Neighborhood Boundaries Become Too Restrictive

Chicago neighborhood names are useful, but they aren't always the best way to define a home search.

Two properties a few blocks apart may appear under different neighborhood names while providing very similar access to transportation, shopping, parks, or other amenities.

Conversely, two homes technically within the same broad area can offer very different surroundings.

Instead of treating neighborhood boundaries as hard walls, consider searching around the locations and features that matter to you.

This can uncover properties you might otherwise miss.

If You're Considering the Suburbs, Compare the Tradeoffs

For some people, the search eventually expands beyond Chicago.

The suburbs can introduce different housing options, lot sizes, transportation patterns, property taxes, municipal services, and commuting considerations.

But “Chicago versus the suburbs” isn't really one comparison.

Evanston, Oak Park, Schaumburg, Oak Lawn, and dozens of other communities each have their own housing stock, transportation options, local services, and real estate markets.

If you're open to both the city and suburbs, define the characteristics you're looking for first and then compare individual areas based on those criteria.

Be Careful With “Best Neighborhood” Lists

Search online and you'll find endless rankings of the best Chicago neighborhoods for virtually every type of person.

They're fine for generating ideas.

They shouldn't make the decision for you.

Terms such as “best,” “safe,” “family-friendly,” “up-and-coming,” or “good neighborhood” can be highly subjective. Your priorities may be completely different from those of whoever created the ranking.

When I'm helping someone evaluate different areas, my role isn't to decide where they should live.

Instead, I can help you understand objective information about the housing market, available properties, pricing, transportation, property characteristics, and other factors so you can decide what works for you.

Use Reliable Sources for the Things That Matter to You

Your real estate agent can be an excellent resource for housing and market information, but some questions are better researched directly.

If crime statistics matter to your decision, review information from appropriate public sources rather than relying on someone's characterization of an area.

If schools are important, research the schools and school districts directly.

If commute time matters, test the actual route.

If you're concerned about future development, zoning, taxes, transportation projects, or municipal services, consult the relevant government or public sources.

The goal is to make your decision based on information that's meaningful to you, rather than someone else's assumptions.

You Don't Have to Choose the Neighborhood First

This is probably the biggest misconception I encounter.

You don't necessarily need to decide:

“I'm moving to Lakeview.”

before starting a home search.

You can instead say:

“Here's my budget. Here's where I need to get to. Here's the type of home I want. And here are the things that matter most to me.”

Then we can identify multiple areas where those criteria intersect.

Sometimes the neighborhood someone ultimately chooses wasn't even on their original list.

That's not a failed search. It's the search doing exactly what it should do.

Finding Your Place in Chicago

Choosing where to live is ultimately a personal decision.

Chicago gives buyers and renters an unusually wide variety of neighborhoods, housing types, transportation options, and price points. That can make the search feel overwhelming, but it also creates opportunities to find combinations you may not have initially considered.

Start with your priorities.

Understand your budget.

Explore more than one area.

And give yourself permission to change your mind as you learn more.

If you're considering buying a home in Chicago or the surrounding suburbs, Brian Somera Group can help you understand how your budget, housing preferences, and location priorities translate into actual options in today's market.

Explore Buying a Home With BSG